The Iconic Bakery begs you to submit your favorite recipe
Let's add "eating" to the list of death and taxes. Everyone pay taxes Everyone will eventually leave this earth...and everyone eats.
Back by popular demand, the Bluffton Icon launches "Iconic Bakery." In it we hope to provide recipes sent by Icon viewers.
Here's how it works:
We want recipes that you'd like to share with others. They could be your family secret recipes or those that are easy for kids to make, or are seasonal - please start with some great summer drinks that help viewers cool off this month. We'll even take your flub baking stories (if you care to admit one).
Don't be shy. If you have 10 recipes, send them all. We'll simply drop one into our column from time to time.
We'd appreciate you providing your name so that we may attach it to the recipe. If you obtained it from someone else, add that person's name, too.
Please provide your recipes in an easy-to-follow format. We hope to simply cut and past from your e-mail to our column.
We'll be dropping in classic Bluffton recipes from time to time, mostly from the "Bluffton Cookbook," the Bible of Bluffton cookbooks, created by the Bluffton Telesis Club. The book commemorated the 75th anniversary of Bluffton College.
Your recipes may be e-mailed to: [email protected].
The Iconic Bakery column is located on the bottom right side of the Icon home page.
And, just to get the oven turned on, here's Joanne Overmyer's "Buttermilk Cookies" recipe, straight from the Bluffton Community Cookbook.
Joanne Overmyer's Buttermilk Cookies
1 3/4 c sugar (3/4 if it should be brown)
1 cup shortening
2 eggs
1 c buttermilk
4 c flour
1 t soda
1 heaping t baking powder
1 t vanilla
Drop on greased cookie sheet. Bake at 375 degrees until done - approximately 10 minues. I like to ice them with a butter pecan icing.
Stories Posted This Week
Saturday, September 19, 2026
Friday, September 18, 2026
- September 18 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Bluffton welcomes incoming class from nine states
- September 2026 Bluffton Lions Club update
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Lima Central Catholic
- Pirate boys soccer win vs. Kenton
- Ramseyer shares grandmother’s fight for citizenship during Bluffton Constitution Day Forum
- How Dillinger robbed a Bluffton bank
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Wednesday, September 16, 2026
Tuesday, September 15, 2026
- Phyllis Ann Reynolds, 77, worked at Citizens National Bank
- Jane Ann (Diller) Thurman, 75, was a nursing home administrator
- Julie C. (Field) Amstutz worked for Putnam County ESC
- Pirate volleyball sweep vs. Wayne Trace
- Findlay Patrol's Donovan promoted to sergeant
- Pirate girls soccer win vs. Delphos Jefferson
- Sept. 14 Bluffton Council: Request for RTA bus signs, pre-1950s unused Maple Grove plots tallied
- Mornings with Mommy resume at Trinity Lutheran