Iconic Bakery: Legendary Icon Refrigerator-Cupboard Pie
Introducing the legendary Icon Refrigerator-Cupboard Pie.
Here’s the approach: Open the refrigerator door (and the kitchen cupboard) and see what you’d like to get rid of.
But, instead tossing things out, you bake it. In a pie.
Wanting to bake a pie, but not knowing which one to tackle, I tried the above approach and it worked.
My wife gave me some Probst Family Farm Maple Syrup for my birthday last week. So, in the back of my mind, maple syrup would play a significant role in the bake.
In my refrigerator I found a container of cottage cheese that was close, but not close enough, to expiring. It needed to go.
With the cottage cheese and maple syrup, here’s what happened next:
Turn the oven to 350.
Add the following in a large mixing bowl:
1 cup flour (I used white, but was tempted to try whole wheat – maybe next time)
1 cup cottage cheese (that’s the exact amount left in the refrigerator)
½ cup brown sugar (that’s all I had in the cupboard and it was solid as a rock)
¼ teaspoon of nutmeg (would have used cinnamon, but that container was empty)
A snitch of salt
½ teaspoon baking soda
2 eggs – whites and yokes – beat with a fork into a pulp and then pour into the above mix
½ teaspoon real vanilla
¾ stick of real butter – sliced, oh so thin
If your brown sugar is like mine, chip it into pieces. Once it’s in the mix it will dissolve.
Stir the above ingredients until you like the texture.
Let’s assume you already have the pie crust.
Pour the refrigerator-cupboard mix into the pie crust.
Bake for 30 minutes on a high rack. Then place the pie on a lower rack, put aluminum foil on top so as to not burn the crust. Decrease the temperature to 315 and give it 30 more minutes.
Take it out of the oven, let it cool. It will probably fall – mine did, but don’t let that bother you. (No doubt took it out too soon. 15 more minutes probably wouldn't hurt.)
If you can wait 30 more minutes you’ll dig into a pie that will make you very happy that you never tossed out the cottage cheese in the first place.
This pie is no beauty contest winner, but, hey, it’s your pie, so it’s a face only the baker will love.
Stories Posted This Week
Tuesday, September 29, 2026
- September 29 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Wapakoneta
- Pirate boys golf 4th at NWC tourney; Meyer places 2nd
- Pirate girls soccer shuts out Lima Central Catholic
- Pirate boys soccer shuts out Lima Central Catholic
- Pirate girls tennis blanks Kenton
- Bluffton Fall Festival overflows with family fun
- Stauber exhibit at Massillon Museum through November 1
Monday, September 28, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, September 21-27
- Alan K. Yoder, O.D., 86, owned Family Eye Care Clinic of Bluffton
- I-75 lane restrictions in Hancock County, Sept. 28-Oct. 2
- Travis Michael Swank, 40, was a salesman
- NetVUE panel highlights chaplaincy, vocation and meaningful work
- Bluffton Presbyterian hosts community-wide Socktober drive
Sunday, September 27, 2026
Saturday, September 26, 2026
Friday, September 25, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, September 25
- Clay, community, and the classroom
- Pirate volleyball loss vs. Crestview
- Pirate girls soccer win vs. Allen East
- Janine Elizabeth (Minnich) Millager, 87, was a lab technician
- Send October 2026 calendar events to the Icon
- New time for Planning and Bluffton Beyond Tomorrow meetings, Sept 29
- Pirate boys golf 10th at sectionals
- Fall Festival activities are all over Bluffton, Sept. 26