Grand jury indicts April 5 Circle K armed robbery suspect
A Hancock County grand jury has indicted a Michigan man in connection with the April 5, armed robbery of the Circle K store located on Commerce Lane in Bluffton.
Police officers arrived within a minute of the robbery and were able to immediately secure the scene.
CLICK HERE FOR STORY ON THE
ROBBERY POSTED EARLIER ON THE ICON.
Officials were able to issue an immediate media release with the suspect photo as well as an alert to regional police agencies.
About a dozen or so tips were communicated to local police officials. An alert Putnam County dispatcher recognized the Bluffton notice as being similar to an alert from Michigan authorities who were investigating an aggravated robbery in Michigan.
Joint cooperation between Putnam County, Leipsic Police, St. Clair Shores (Michigan), and Bluffton led to a solid suspect being identified.
Bluffton officials presented their case to the grand jury earlier this week. The grand jury indicted Eric J. Auchmuty, 31, of Eastpoint, Mich., for the robbery.
Auchmuty has not been taken into custody as of today. He is wanted in both Michigan and Ohio for armed robbery.
Stories Posted This Week
Thursday, August 27, 2026
- One seriously injured in Union Township crash
- President Sider introduces Reinvest, Reinvent, Reimagine framework in State of the University
- August 27 Bluffton High School athletics lineup, streaming
- Bluffton girls tennis loss vs. Wapakoneta
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Rockets
- EMS Chief Noah Babcock is Sept. 1 Bluffton Lions speaker
- Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology): Air pollution and rheumatoid arthritis
Wednesday, August 26, 2026
- Aug. 24 Bluffton Council recap: MHCO duplexes and long range Village planning
- Beaverdam installs AED at village park
- Pirate girls tennis edges St. Mary
- Pirate boys soccer tames Bearcats
- WIP Wednesday: Window on your world
- OPEN POLL: What do farmers wish non-farmers knew?
- 2026 PorchFest preview: LeBlanc Zepplin, CAWZ, Marlena Rock
Tuesday, August 25, 2026
- Headlines on the Ada Icon, August 22- 25
- Sue Corle worked for Ohio Northern University
- Pandora's Niese Ag LLC wins 2026 Red Gold Stewardship award
- Goshen College innovation leader to explore AI through a liberal arts lens
- Pirate volleyball loses to Shawnee
- Pirate boys golf sweeps NWC tri
- Figurines and household items recontextualized in "Amusings" exhibit
- Bruce Chesser: A Ceramic Retrospective, Aug. 24-Sept 26
- Bluffton Lions reach 80% of All Abilities Playground fundraising goal