HS football: Pandora-Gilboa up next
By Cort Reynolds
BLUFFTON - Host Bluffton ended the game with 21 unanswered points to defeat local non-league rival Cory-Rawson 42-26 in their traditional opener at Harmon Field Friday night.
Four turnovers and a blocked punt cost the Hornets mightily.
Box score at bottom of story -
The Pirates led 21-20 at halftime. But with just 40 seconds left in the third period, C-R scored on a 21-yard pass to grab a five-point lead. The two-point conversion pass failed, keeping the margin at 26-21.
Yet on the final play of the third quarter, Pirate Tyson Shutler scampered 68 yards to paydirt to give the hosts the lead back for good.
The two-point conversion run failed to limit the lead to 27-26 heading into the final stanza.
After forcing a three-and-out series, Bluffton then seized control with a big special teams play. The Pirates blocked a Hornet punt and with 10:14 remaining, Zavier O'Neal recovered the loose pigskin in the end zone for a momentum-changing touchdown.
This time the two-point conversion run by quarterback Nate Schaadt was good, giving the Pirates a 35-26 cushion.
Then with 3:53 left to play, Schaadt put the game out of reach when he connected with Andrew Wehrly on a 21-yard TD toss. The extra point kick by Kyle Koontz provided the final margin of 16.
The game began with a seesaw, high-scoring first period.
Bluffton scored first on a one-yard run by Baylor Garmatter with 8:07 left in the first period. The extra point try was no good, and Cory tied it on a 50-yard TD run by Tommy Stauffer. The extra point kick gave the visitors a 7-6 edge with 4:39 to go in the opening stanza.
Shutler regained the lead for Bluffton when he scampered nine yards to paydirt with 2:58 still left in the eventful first quarter. Shutler also ran in the two-pointer to give the hosts a 14-7 lead.
Cory came right back to score on a 61-yard run by Deontae Davis just 48 seconds later. The extra point boot tied it 14-14.
Garmatter's six-yard TD run and a Koontz PAT gave Bluffton a 21-14 lead with 11:53 left in the first half.
However, a one-yard Davis plunge at the 10:14 juncture brought the visitors within a point. Yet the extra point kick missed to keep Bluffton ahead 21-20, an edge it took to halftime.
The Pirates then outscored C-R 21-6 after intermission to win going away.
C-R out-gained Bluffton 412-365 in total yardage, running 59 plays to 54 by the victors. The Hornets averaged seven yards a play to 6.8 by the Pirates. Cory amassed 22 first downs to 19 by Bluffton.
Bluffton rushed for 330 yards on 48 tries, a 6.9 average per run. C-R netted 245 yards on 33 rushes (7.4 avg.). The Pirates possessed the ball for 25:16 compared to 22:44 by the Hornets.
Tucker Neff led the Pirates with 143 yards rushing on 21 carries. Shutler contributed 108 yards on seven rushes. Schaadt amassed 50 yards on 13 tries while Austin Reynolds added 20 yards on two carries.
C-R completed 12 of 26 passes for 167 yards, while the Pirates completed three of six aerials for 67 yards.
Shutler caught two passes for 14 yards. Schaadt was 2-2 passing for 35 yards, and Shutler went 1-4 throwing the pigskin.
Davis led C-R with 166 yards rushing and two TDs. Stauffer added 82 yards and one score on nine carries. Stauffer also completed eight of 21 passes for 105 yards and one TD with three interceptions.
Nick Thompson led the Hornets with four receptions for 62 yards.
1 2 3 4 F
Bluf 14 7 6 15 42
C-R 14 6 6 0 26
Bluffton (1-0) hosts Pandora-Gilboa (0-1) in week two. The Rockets lost 32-18 at home to Columbus Grove in their traditional local rivalry opener.
Stories Posted This Week
Thursday, September 3, 2026
- September 3 Bluffton High School athletics lineup, streaming
- ONU mobile clinic schedule, serving Hardin, Allen, Putnam and Auglaize counties
- Bluffton front porches and back yards hum during 2026 PorchFest
- Before Our Weakness Gets Too Strong: Science to modulate our immune system
- Meet the Pirate cross country runners, Fall 2026
Wednesday, September 2, 2026
- Bluffton University offers $1,000 annual award to enrollees who visit campus
- Pirate golf 3rd in NWC quad
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Elida
- Pirate boys soccer loss vs. Van Buren
- Pirate girls soccer win vs. Spencerville
- August 2026 land transfers in the Bluffton school district
- Bluffton alumnus to share grandmother's fight for U.S. citizenship
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, August 2026
- Pirate golfers split tri
- ICYMI: August 2026 Bluffton Icon Highlights
- Nisly to present colloquium on Hemingway’s “The Old Man and the Sea”
- Bluffton School district mails 2026-2027 Summer District Newsletter
- Emmanuel UCC is 2026 Bluffton Family Y coed softball champion
Monday, August 31, 2026
Sunday, August 30, 2026
- Vickie Diane Little was a registered nurse
- Nancy Ann Wheeler Andrews worked for First Federal Savings and Loan
- Donor generosity powers Bluffton U technology upgrade
- Pirates girls soccer blanked by Sylvania
- Pirate volleyball drops 2 in close tri-match
- Pirate cross country opens Fall 2026 at DSJ Invite
- Back to School Days at Bluffton Public Library