Lady Pirates knocked off by Paulding 2nd half
By Cort Reynolds
PAULDING - Host Paulding outscored Bluffton 41-19 in the second half to rally for a 62-46 Northwest Conference girls basketball victory Thursday night.
Bluffton led 12-9 after one period and extended their edge to 27-21 at halftime as Laykin Garmatter splashed five first-half triples.
But the Lady Pirates scored just five third-period points and got outscored 27-14 in the final stanza to lose by 16.
The defeat dropped the Pirate girls record to 9-3 overall and they fell from the unbeaten ranks in NWC play at 3-1. Meanwhile, Paulding improved to 9-3 overall and 2-2 in the NWC with the win.
Bluffton junior guard Laykin Garmatter led all scorers with 22 points on the strength of six trifectas. She netted 19 of her points in the first half. Sophomore Kylie Stackhouse added eight markers.
Panther senior wing Chelsi Giesige led all scorers with 21 points. She scored eight key points in each of the third and fourth periods.
Paulding junior guard Jalynn Parrett contributed nine of her 15 points in the fourth quarter. Junior Leigha Egnor added eight markers.
Paulding outscored Bluffton 14-5 in the third quarter to rally from six points behind at intermission to a 35-32 lead heading to the final stanza.
The Panthers then hit 13 of 18 free throws in the fourth quarter en route to a whopping 27-point closing period.
The Bluffton girls canned 16 baskets, including nine two-pointers and seven goals from three-point range. The Pirate girls converted seven of 19 from the charity stripe (37 percent).
The Panther girls sank 20 field goals, with 17 deuces and three three-point baskets. Paulding converted 19 of 27 at the foul line (70 percent).
Paulding (9-3, 2-2 NWC)
Parrett 5 4-4 15, McCullough 1 1-2 3, Pease 2 3-6 7, Egnor 2 4-4 8, C. Giesige 8 5-5 21, A. Giesige 2 1-4 7, Estle 0 1-2 1.
Totals: 20/19-27/62. 3-pointers: A. Giesige 2, Parrett 1.
Bluffton (9-3, 3-1 NWC)
B. Garmatter 2 0-0 5, L. Garmatter 7 2-3 22, White 1 0-0 2, Stackhouse 3 2-4 8, Monday 1 2-2 4, Scoles 0 0-1 0, Bricker 0 0-1 0, Schaadt 2 1-8 5.
Totals: 16/7-19/46. 3-pointers: L. Garmatter 6, B. Garmatter 1.
1 2 3 4 F
Pau 9 12 14 27 62
Bluf 12 15 5 14 46
League-leading Bluffton (6-2 home) is idle for a week before hosting winless Lincolnview (0-11, 0-3 NWC) Thursday, January 16.
Stories Posted This Week
Saturday, October 17, 2026
Friday, October 16, 2026
- Production offers a modern take on the story of St. Clare of Assisi
- Bluffton volleyball edged in 5 by Van Buren
- Pirate girls soccer tie O-G
- October 16 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Bluffton Council recap: Officers honored for 25 years of service
- Bluffton Clean Up teams up with Troop 3256 Cub Scouts
- Ada FFA: Feeding the Farmers
- Nov. 7 Fall Community Day at Bluffton University
- Quarry Farm Nature Preserve news for Fall 2026
Thursday, October 15, 2026
- DeWine announces $200M Rural Health Transformation program award
- Herb program with Marge Lafollette, Oct. 15
- Prairie seeding activity at Bluffton University, October 24
- Food for thought: Choline for the brain
- Results for 5K on October 2, Bluffton University Homecoming event
- 15 minutes with Sherry Miller, senior center activities coordinator
Wednesday, October 14, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 14
- CANCELLED Main St. closure on October 15
- Frederick Clyde Warren founded True-2-Form Plastics
- Pirate boys soccer beats Wapak in regular season finale
- Pirate girls soccer defeats Liberty Center
- Mennonite pastor to explore ‘good news’ in creation
- Bluffton University earns recognition in U.S. News & World Report rankings
- Obituary for Deborah "Debbie" Welch, 74
- Spirits and exorcism presentation during University Spiritual Life Week Forum
- Dodging bullets: Bluffton oral history 90+ years after Dillinger robbery
- Nora Matthews named BHS Student of the Month for September 2026
- ICAPP analysis on charter status and local autonomy
Tuesday, October 13, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 13
- Bluffton area Women in Business meeting October 15
- Leo club glasses collection
- Night at the (Swiss Historical) Museum, October 24
- Woodcarving ornament workshop at Swiss Heritage Center
- Barefoot nature walks at the Nature Preserve
- Pirate volleyball seeded 4th
- Beavers sports roundup, October 6-11
- Bluffton leaf pickup scheduled for last week of October
- Pirate boys soccer shuts out Bellefontaine
- Watch an after school movie at the Bluffton Public Library