Girls' soccer: BHS stays unbeaten in NWC
By Cort Reynolds
BLUFFTON - Host Bluffton soundly defeated Delphos Jefferson 4-1 in Northwest Conference girls soccer action Monday night at Steinmetz Field.
The comeback win upped the Lady Pirate record to 4-2-1 overall and 3-0 in NWC play, good for a first-place tie. In their last five matches, the red-hot Pirate girls have posted four wins and one tie.
The Lady Wildcats fell to 1-5-1 and 0-2-1 in the NWC with the defeat.
Laykin Garmatter netted two goals to pace Bluffton to victory.
DJ's Kyrstin Moore tallied the game's first goal in the 16th minute, and the Wildcats led 1-0 until late in the first half.
Garmatter then tied it 1-1 on her first goal with under four minutes left before intermission. Then just about five minutes into the second half, she scored again to put Bluffton ahead for good.
Pirate Reagan Mittendorf hit the back of the net in the 69th minute to extend the lead to 3-1. Sami Scoles added the final goal in the 73rd minute to put the game out of reach.
Mittendorf, Clara Matthews and Allison Diller each passed out one assist.
The Bluffton offense fired 39 shots, 22 of which were on goal.
DJ mustered just two shots against the tough Pirate defense, with only one on target.
Pirate goalie Julia Mehaffie made one save. Busy Wildcat goalie Lillian Baugh was credited with 18 stops.
The Lady Pirate kickers play a showdown match at NWC co-leader Columbus Grove (4-3, 3-0 NWC) Thursday, September 17.
Stories Posted This Week
Monday, October 12, 2026
Sunday, October 11, 2026
Saturday, October 10, 2026
Friday, October 9, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 9
- Pirate girls soccer loss vs. St. Marys
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Carey
- “The Trumpet Player” sculpture at Bluffton University receives conservation grant
- October 9 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Plenty of action at Oct 10 Dillinger robbery reenactment and motorcycle show
- Caitlyn Couch junior piano recital, October 16
- Bluffton community survey opens for Active Transportation Plan
Thursday, October 8, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines on Thursday, October 8
- St. John Bible Church to host "Refocus on Purpose" workshop
- Royal riches: Gout
- Has Bluffton made a birder out of you?
- BPL Afterschool activity: Curious Kids Club
- Book and pizza tasting at Bluffton Public Library
- Final 50 for 250 performance at BPL
- Walking through the Suter Corn Maze
- Resident feedback sought for Regional Transportation Plan
- Bluffton University honors three for service, achievement and leadership