Pirate girls soccer wins 2025-2026 NWC title
Beats Grove in showdown to win league
By Cort Reynolds
CORRECTED VERSION / BLUFFTON – The Bluffton High School girls soccer team beat visiting rival Columbus Grove 2-1 in a battle of league unbeatens to capture the Northwest Conference championship at Steinmetz Field and punctuate Pirate Senior Night on Tuesday, September 30.
Bluffton senior Aubrey Burkholder netted the tie-breaking goal in the 53rd minute to put the Pirates ahead for good, 2-1. Neither team could score over the final 27 minutes as Bluffton preserved the win and won the title.
The Pirate girls finished 6-0 in the NWC and improved to 7-7 overall with the hard-fought win. The victory clinched the fifth outright league title in program history, and seventh crown overall.
Twelve Pirate seniors went out with a league-clinching win in their final home regular season match.
Meanwhile, CG fell to 9-2-2 overall and 4-1 in NWC play after the defeat.
The two rivals have shared the last six NWC titles, with Bluffton winning four of those crowns. Grove has won two league titles.
Bluffton sophomore Willow Derstine started the scoring vs. CG with a goal in the 19th minute via an assist by Keyrsten Kleman.
Grove’s Ruth Myers equalized it in the 27th minute with a goal to make it 1-1. It stayed that way into halftime, and for 26 minutes total until Burkholder netted the unassisted game-winner.
Bluffton directed six of its 12 shots on goal. Grove put six of its 10 shots on target.
Bluffton senior keeper Kynzie Ewing made five saves, while CG keeper Erianne Heffner was credited with four saves.
Seniors Mya McDougle, Avery Ulrey, Jenna Downey, Blair Utendorf, Lauren Dearth, Lilly Dagani, Burkholder, Macy Schaadt, Ewing, Jaicelyn Morris, Claire Phillips and Alli Shilling celebrated a conference crown with the victory at Steinmetz Field.
The Pirates were 3-0 at home in NWC play and 4-4 overall at Steinmetz this season.
The Pirates play at WBL foe St. Marys (5-6-3) on Thursday, October 2.
◾️
Stories Posted This Week
Saturday, October 10, 2026
Friday, October 9, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 9
- Pirate girls soccer loss vs. St. Marys
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Carey
- “The Trumpet Player” sculpture at Bluffton University receives conservation grant
- October 9 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Plenty of action at Oct 10 Dillinger robbery reenactment and motorcycle show
- Caitlyn Couch junior piano recital, October 16
- Bluffton community survey opens for Active Transportation Plan
Thursday, October 8, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines on Thursday, October 8
- St. John Bible Church to host "Refocus on Purpose" workshop
- Royal riches: Gout
- Has Bluffton made a birder out of you?
- BPL Afterschool activity: Curious Kids Club
- Book and pizza tasting at Bluffton Public Library
- Final 50 for 250 performance at BPL
- Walking through the Suter Corn Maze
- Resident feedback sought for Regional Transportation Plan
- Bluffton University honors three for service, achievement and leadership
Wednesday, October 7, 2026
Tuesday, October 6, 2026
- Bluffton Area Chamber of Commerce monthly meeting, Friday, Oct. 9
- Fire extinguished at SRK Industries, plant resumed operation same day
- Bluffton girls tie Grove in NWC showdown
- Pirate volleyball falls to powerhouse Patriots
- BHS GOAT: Latin teacher Margaret Weaver
- Library patrons invited to showcase their collections or causes
- September 2026 land transfers in the Bluffton school district