Mary Jane Lugibihl started Harlan's Bar-B-Q and Catering with her husband
Mary Jane (Carr) Lugibihl, 96, of Pandora, died at 12:02 p.m. at Hilty Memorial Home, Pandora, on April 14, 2013. She was born on April 7, 1917, at the family’s “Hickory Farm” near Bluffton, to William G. and Eva M. (Deitler) Carr. She attended grade school at the Hickory One-Room Country School and graduated from Pandora High School where she excelled as a member of the women’s basketball team.
On July 5, 1952, she married Harlan E. Lugibihl who preceded her in death on Jan. 24, 1992.
She and her husband were co-owners of Harlan’s Bar-B-Q and Catering and served thousands at community events and fundraisers throughout Ohio. She also worked earlier at the Amstutz Cannery, Triplett Company in Bluffton, and the First National Bank of Pandora. She also was a charter member of the Asi No Mas club, Pandora.
She was a veteran of World War II. She attained the rank of Staff Sergent in the Women’s Army Corps (WACs) and served at Oglethorpe Army Base, Ga., New York City, and at Wright Patterson Base in Dayton. In 2009 she was honored to join the Honor Flight of Northwest Ohio in touring Washington, D.C., and the World War II Memorial. She was a 65-year member of the American Legion Post of Pandora.
Surviving are two sisters, Pauline Bibler and Barbara Gardiner of Hilty Memorial Home in Pandora, and her sister-in-law, Evelyn Lugibihl of Pandora. Preceding her in death was her sister and brother-in-law, Marjorie M. and Harold C. Zuercher, Pandora, brother and sister-in-law, David W. and Catharine (Alspach) Carr, Vashon, Wash., brother-in-law Wallace Lugibihl, Pandora, and sister-in-law, Gertrude Drummer (Bob), Pandora.
She is survived by numerous nieces and nephews: William D. Carr (Beng Imm), Vashon, Wash.; Cathleen Carr, deceased, Vashon, Wash.; Ned C. Zuercher (Cindy), Pandora; Deborah J. Backus (David), Anthem, Ariz.; Peter T. Gardiner (Kristi), Port Orchard, Wash.; Colette A. Mata, Findlay; Gregory C. Zuercher (Susan), Findlay; David L. Gardiner, deceased, Mill Valley, Calif.; Timothy C. Bibler (Shirley), Springboro; Cheryl Pingle (Dan), Bowling Green; Dana Lugibihl (Jenny), Port Clinton; Arthur Armbrecht (Gail), Bemus Point, N.Y.; Gary Armbrecht (Chris), Grand Rapids, Mich.; Bill Armbrecht (Patty), Sandusky; Carl Drummer, Oklahoma City, Ok.; Gretchen Holtgreven (Tom), Lima; and Susie Drummer, Houghton Lake, Mich.
Friends and family may visit on Tuesday, April 16, from 2-4 p.m. and 6-8 p.m. at Chiles-Laman Funeral Home, Bluffton.
She was a member of the Ebenezer Mennonite Church, Bluffton. Her funeral services will be held there at 11 a.m. on Wednesday, April 17, with visitation one hour prior to funeral service.
Burial will follow at the church cemetery with the Putnam County Veterans Memorial Squad performing full military rites.
Memorial contributions in her name may be made to Ebenezer Mennonite Church. Online condolences may be sent to www.chiles-lamanfh.com
Stories Posted This Week
Friday, July 10, 2026
- Find and update Bluffton Civic Organization contact information
- 12th Ride to Remember rolls through Bluffton July 11
- Rumpke trash and recycling guidelines for Bluffton, July 2026
- Beaverdam 4-H report for July 6
- Take a look at Blufftonicon.com/calendar (video)
- Newark Earthworks program on historical indigenous architecture, July 22
Thursday, July 9, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, July 9
- Share the bridge
- Jeff Richards is new Bluffton Elementary principal
- Officer Dominic Francis Memorial Bike & Jeep Run, Aug. 8
- Sheriff seeks information in June 29 Meijer shooting investigation
- Down on the Farm celebration of America 250, July 19
- Enjoy this summer without doing damage
- Register now for July 23 Words and Wine event
- Village of Bluffton to serve BSC Community meal
Wednesday, July 8, 2026
- Allen County Auditor explanation of Ohio House Bill 186 Inflation Cap Credit
- Shoemaker sentenced to 27 years on child pornography charges
- St. John's UCC to host Bluffton bike swap
- Beaverdam Bunch reports: July 29 meeting
- July 28 speed puzzle competition at Bluffton Public Library
- Galley Book Group to meet at Bluffton Public Library
Tuesday, July 7, 2026
- Highway Patrol reports on July Fourth fatal crashes
- 2026 Porch Fest preview: Blanchard Creek Band, Conner Raines and AJ Knepper
- Take an RTA bus trip to Delphos on July 29
- Senior Center to host Route 66 Centennial trip
- Family-friendly Jurassic Adventure Escape Room, July 17 and 18
- Critters, Flitters, and Gallinippers: SCHS 2nd Saturday, July 11
- Register now for Bluffton Public Library's Read with a Dog
- Orange Twp. receives ODOT request to close two US 30 intersections