New owners for Fortman Insurance, and company stays in the family
Jonathan Fortman and Zachary Fortman, sons of John and Catherine Fortman, recently purchased the Ottawa and Bluffton businesses of Fortman Insurance Services.
Company founders, John and Catherine, will continue to stay active in the business.
John Fortman started Fortman Insurance Services in November 1978, and his wife, Catherine, joined him in 1982.
After leasing buildings in downtown Ottawa, the company relocated to the Westrick Realty building. In 1991, Fortman’s built its current office on State Route 65, Ottawa. A 2004 addition doubled the size of the building.
On July 1, 2011, Fortman opened its second office at 115 N. Main St., Bluffton. They have four licensed agents working from the Bluffton office.
Jonathan Fortman joined the business in 2003, and is a licensed health and life agent. He works with individuals and businesses and assists with their group medical insurance and ancillary coverages.
Fortman’s health and life agents are Laurie Basinger, Kathy Green, Tammy Evans, Megan Hohman, Ruth Ann Bair, Nichole Schroeder and Catherine Fortman.
Zachary Fortman joined the business in 2010 as a licensed property and casualty agent. Other property and casualty agents are John Fortman, Pam Eickholt, Amy Baker, Marla Santomieri, Nancy Scalf, Betty Wagner and Rachel Miller.
Fortman Insurance Services specializes in: farm, home, renter's, vehicle, commercial, Medicare products, life, individual and group health and ancillary coverages.
Over the last 37 years, Fortman Insurance has grown to l6 licensed agents. All agents reside in and around the Ottawa and the Bluffton area.
Fortman Insurance is very community involved with the American Cancer Society, United Way and other projects.
They company will soon be holding its 9th annual corn hole tournament, benefitting the United Way. Other fundraisers include Relay for Life/American Cancer Society.
“We’d like to extend a special thank you to all of our clients for their support and business with their agency over the last 37 years,” said John and Catherine. “Our team looks forward to continuing to service insurance needs in Bluffton.”
Besides all four Fortmans still working in the business, the firm continues to grow and add new staff and team members. Fortman Insurance Services now have 16 licensed agents.
Stories Posted This Week
Friday, October 30, 2026
- Main St. runway for Trick or Treaters
- October 30 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- What Kind of Paradise author joins book club by Zoom, Nov. 4
- Check out November 2026 events at Bluffton Public Library
- Scarecrow voting ends at midnight, Oct. 31
- Annual meeting and dinner for Senior Center members, November 9
- November 2026 Community Meals at the Senior Center
- Pirate girls soccer edged in shootout by Big Green in district final
Thursday, October 29, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 29
- Bluffton chamber welcomes six new members in October 2026
- Scam talk with Chief Ryan Burkholder
- Apollo Career Center honored as Gold Star Institution
- Peanut brittle time at the Senior Center begins Nov. 9
- Bluffton University Forum explores faith, hope and care for creation
- Business Collective networking night, Nov. 5
- Radio play staging of It's a Wonderful Life on Nov. 29
- Test-to-Treat not Trick-or-Treat
- If only we could put these fall days on pause
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
Monday, October 26, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, October 19-25
- Ada Icon headlines, October 26
- November 13 fish fry at Emmanuel UCC
- Citizens National Bank customer appreciation day, October 30
- Bluffton University offers free agricultural and environmental field trips
- Trinity Trunk or Treat, October 31
- Public invited to Bluffton Lions program with President Sider