Loaded with experience
By Sam Brauen www.blufftonpirates.com
Loaded with experience, the time is now for the Bluffton Lady Pirate basketball team.
Bluffton returns the top seven scorers from last year’s squad that went 17-7 overall and 6-2 in Northwest Conference play. At the heart of it all are seniors Alivia Koenig, Averey Rumer, Katie Prater and Ashley Eachus. Koenig, Prater and Rumer have started nearly every game of their high school career and together with Eachus provide an experienced, formidable foundation.
Juniors Libby Schaadt, Kayla White and Brinkley Garmatter are returning letterwinners as is sophomore Laykin Garmatter.
Alivia Koenig eclipsed the 1,000 point barrier last season, just the fourth Bluffton girls player to accomplish the feat. Koenig has chosen to continue her basketball (and golf) career at Urbana University beginning next fall. The sharpshooter will very likely eclipse Caity Matter’s career three point made record of 209. Alivia enters the season at 187, unofficially. Koenig averaged 14.5 points per game and was a first team All league selection for the third time last season.
Averey Rumer was also a double digit scorer, pouring in 10.6 points per contest in 2017-18. The versatile forward grabbed a team high 6 rebounds per game and was also a First Team Northwest Conference selection.
Libby Schaadt averaged 9.3 points per game and nabbed 5.9 rebounds per game last season. Katie Prater averaged 6 points, 3 rebounds and 3 assists per contest on her way to an Honorable Mention selection from the NWC.
Kayla White (5 ppg), Ashley Eachus (3 ppg), Laykin Garmatter (2 ppg) and Brinkley Garmatter (1 ppg) round out the returning scorers.
Per Head Coach Eric Garmatter (8th season, 90-71 career record) Grace Myers, Reagan Mittendorf, Kylie Monday and Kylie Stackhouse will provide depth off the bench.
For the first time in a few seasons, the Pirates will also field a full Junior Varsity team as the program has expanded growth. Assisting Garmatter this season are Scott Gleason, Steve Mittendorf and Cindy Lee.
The schedule for Bluffton starts out like it has for over 20 years: The McDonald’s Holiday Tournament.
The Pirates have faced off against Arlington for several years in a row in the Championship game of the tournament but first things first, a date with Cory-Rawson on Friday evening.
The Pirates have a challenging out of conference schedule with contests against teams such as Ottoville, Liberty Benton, Elida, Upper Scioto Valley and Arcadia along the way. The NWC slate is difficult enough. Bluffton will be looking to upend reigning league champion Columbus Grove and avenge a loss to Spencerville last season as well.
Stories Posted This Week
Thursday, October 22, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 22
- ICAPP study: Ohioans strongly oppose data center expansion and tax breaks
- October 22 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Pirate girls soccer ousts rival Allen East in sectionals
- Strawberry Fields Forever: Fruit polyphenols and brain health
- Last call for Bluffton Cars & Coffee for 2026
- Icon calendar gets a little more elbow room
- Bluffton Board of Education recap: Contracts for coaches and new bus driver
- Bluffton Lions Club update for October 2026
- Bluffton chamber photo competition display and reception announced
- Bluejays and buzzards catch the eye of this Accounting prof
Wednesday, October 21, 2026
- Ada Icon headlines, October 21
- Village of Beaverdam requests suggestions for park grant application
- Charles “Chuck” Wendall Collins, 63, owned Eagle Press Repairs
- Dwain L. Leiber, 87, owned Leiber Garage
- Kimberly Dawn Murphy, 55, taught at Findlay City Schools
- Kaleidoscope Farms honoring veterans, thanking current troops, Nov. 8
- Filmmaker to preview documentary exploring life beyond incarceration
- ONU mobile health clinic at Senior Center on Oct. 28
Tuesday, October 20, 2026
- Columbus Grove-Bluffton Rd. closure planned for up to three weeks
- Two Pirate volleyball players make 1st team All-NWC
- 3 Pirate girls 1st team All-NWC soccer
- Pirates dominate All-NWC boys soccer awards
- Local filmmaker focuses on memories made by people and places
- Bluffton Public Library: Medicare 101
- BHS artists prepare Yankee Doodle Christmas Trees for Jingle Bell Stroll
Monday, October 19, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, October 14-18
- Ada Icon headlines, October 19
- JessExpress Travel is the Icon's newest advertiser
- Gatchel 7th in girls, Pirates 4th at NWC cross country meet
- Veterans invited to Pandora-Gilboa banquet, November 10
- Wearable sculptures featured in exhibit On Soft Ground
- Historic depot rentals offered for meetings and parties