Lady Pirates visit 8-3 Paulding on Thursday
By Cort Reynolds
BLUFFTON - Visiting Elida outscored Bluffton 14-6 in the fourth period to win a 53-46 non-conference girls basketball battle Saturday afternoon.
Bluffton led 14-7 after one period of play, yet Elida roared back to tie it 30-30 with a 23-point second quarter outburst. The Pirate girls inched back in front 40-39 heading to the final stanza, but they went ice cold with just two baskets and a foul shot in the last period.
The loss dropped the Pirate girl record to 9-2 as the Lady Bulldogs ended their nine-game win string. Meanwhile, Elida improved to 5-6 with the victory.
Junior guard Laykin Garmatter led the Pirate girls with 15 points. Senior post Libby Schaadt contributed a dozen markers, while sophomore Kylie Monday added 10 points.
Elida junior Amira Freeman led all players with 18 points, as she scored nine markers in each of the second and fourth periods. Elida outscored Bluffton 37-22 in those key stanzas. E. Johnson added 15 points.
The Bluffton girls canned 17 baskets, including 11 two-pointers and six goals from three-point range. The Pirate girls converted six of 11 from the charity stripe (64 percent).
The Bulldog girls sank 17 field goals, four of which were three-point baskets. Elida converted 15 of 18 at the foul line (83 percent).
The loss also snapped a six-game Pirate home win streak.
Elida 53 (5-6)
Mitchell 2 2-2 6, Am. Freeman 4 8-8 18, Vincent 0 1-2 1, Ad. Freeman 4 3-3 11, Reese 1 0-1 2, E. Johnson 6 1-2 15.
Totals: 17/15-18/53. 3-pointers: Johnson 2, Am. Freeman 2.
Bluffton 46 (9-2)
B. Garmatter 0, L. Garmatter 5 1-2 15, White 0 0-2 0, Stackhouse 2 0-0 4, Busch 2 0-0 5, Monday 3 3-5 10, Schaadt 5 2-4 12. Totals: 17/6-11/46. 3-pointers: L. Garmatter 4, Monday 1, Busch 1.
1 2 3 4 F
Elid 7 23 9 14 53
Bluf 14 16 10 6 46
League-leading Bluffton (3-0 NWC) visits Northwest Conference foe Paulding (8-3, 1-2 NWC) Thursday, January 9 to resume conference play. Bluffton is 3-0 on the road this season.
The Lady Pirates (6-2 home) had not lost since November 22, when they fell 37-30 to visiting Cory-Rawson in the season-opener.
Stories Posted This Week
Tuesday, August 25, 2026
- Carolyn Corle worked for Ohio Northern University
- Pandora's Niese Ag LLC wins 2026 Red Gold Stewardship award
- Goshen College innovation leader to explore AI through a liberal arts lens
- Pirate volleyball loses to Shawnee
- Pirate boys golf sweeps NWC tri
- Figurines and household items recontextualized in "Amusings" exhibit
- Bruce Chesser: A Ceramic Retrospective, Aug. 24-Sept 26
- Bluffton Lions reach 80% of All Abilities Playground fundraising goal
Monday, August 24, 2026
Sunday, August 23, 2026
Saturday, August 22, 2026
Friday, August 21, 2026
- Marjorie Jean (Reams) Montgomery was a homemaker
- Meet the Bluffton Pirate football team, Fall 2026
- Ada Icon stories posted this week, August 17-21
- Aug. 22 Bluffton Cars & Coffee reminder
- Pirate girls soccer shuts out Anna in home opener
- Pirate volleyball win vs. Wildcats
- Pirate boys soccer rallies past Archbold
- Capture the essence of Bluffton in photos
- Pirate girls golf places 9th at SJCC Invite
- Call for actors for Dillinger reenactment on October 10