2023 Bluffton Trout Derby opens a winning season at Buckeye Lake
Hundreds of prizes still in play
By Paula Scott
In keeping with Bluffton Sportsmen’s Club traditions, the May 7 Bluffton Trout Derby provided anglers with an opportunity to fish for stocked trout in Buckeye Lake and to win prizes provided by local individuals and businesses (booklet attached HERE).
CONTINUES WITH ADDITIONAL PHOTOS
The biggest potential prize is designated for whoever catches the #1 tagged trout on the day of the derby. This year the fish was named “Ole M&R” in honor of M&R Plumbing & Heating, one of the five original sponsors of the event.
The prize for catching the #1 trout on Derby Day would have been $2,000 for the fisherman and $2,000 for the winning ticket holder. The jackpot is built up with $5 donations. When the Icon spoke to club president Tom Augsburger, the #1 fish was still swimming in Buckeye Lake. If it is caught by Labor Day, it is worth $200.
The Bluffton Sportsmen’s Club stocked Buckeye Lake with 400 pounds of fish, which is about 400 fish. The largest fish was over six pounds—which was caught on Derby day. The 12-page Trout Derby booklet lists 215 tagged 2023 trout.
While fishing action began at 2:00 p.m., organizers were ready for early birds. Boy Scout Troop 256 began selling concessions at 8:00 a.m. An 11:00 a.m. Chicken Barbecue was provided by Ted & Don’s at the Depot clubhouse.
The non-profit club leases and stocks the Buckeye and the larger Cob Lake (a.k.a. The National Quarry) from the Village of Bluffton. Cob Lake is stocked in the fall.
The club averages 650-700 members per year. Augsburger notes that Bluffton is one of the few fishing clubs with trout. The club president explained that walleye and other fish aren’t as quick to bite. On Derby Day 2023, there were 55 tagged trout turned in.
Fish are tagged on the lower jaw with a current year numbered steel cylinder tag. To collect prizes through Labor Day, take the tag to The Dough Hook, 117 N. Main. A certificate will be given, which is then presented with the tag to the sponsor to collect the prize.
2023 Memberships are available for $30/yr 14 and up, $10/yr 13 and under. Memberships are available at The Dough Hook, Kibbee's Carryout, Bluffton, and Ted's Market, Pandora, TNT Firearms LLC, Findlay.
The 2024 Bluffton Trout Derby will be the 80th event hosted by the Bluffton Sportsmen’s Club.




Stories Posted This Week
Saturday, September 6, 2025
Friday, September 5, 2025
- NEW DATE Thayer Rd. closure for bridge repair begins Sept. 15
- Beavers sports roundup, Aug 29-Sept 4
- Pirate boys soccer shut out by Ottoville
- Pirate girls soccer edged by Bath
- Pirate volleyball sweeps Elmwood
- 1-year anniversary celebration of Elm St. businesses on Sept. 6
- Sugden and Windle finalists in CreativeOhio Champion Advocacy Awards
Thursday, September 4, 2025
- Pirate girls tennis loss to Shawnee
- Lugabill Rd. closed for paving on Sept. 4
- Pirate volleyball loss at Liberty-Benton
- Pirate boys golf win vs. Ada
- Ultra-processed foods: Impact on children’s health
- Check out Bluffton Public Library’s September 2025 programs and services
- Active shooter training to be held at Apollo Career Center
- Etc. Volunteers Garden created by Tim Byers
- Letter: Darrell Groman celebrates 40 years of optometric practice
Wednesday, September 3, 2025
- Obituary for Dawn Inniger Curth
- Pirate boys soccer tie vs. Van Buren
- Gritty Pirate tennis win vs. Defiance
- Pirate volleyball rallies past Arlington
- Bluffton girls soccer pounds Knights
- Pirate golfers edged in tight NWC tri
- President Sider charts Bluffton’s path forward
- Physical therapy technique presentation, Sept. 18