Arlington led by 19; BHS caught up, but ended on the short end
By Sam Brauen www.blufftonpirates.com
(OTTAWA) - In the first week of the girls' basketball season Bluffton and Arlington met in the finals of the McDonald’s Holiday Tournament.
The Red Devils won the contest 40-39 and Bluffton hoped to get some revenge in the real tournament, the OHSAA Districts.
Arlington led by 19 heading into the fourth quarter but Bluffton braved a valiant comeback and cut the lead to two points with one minute to go, however Arlington was a sterling 6/6 from the free line in the final minute and grabbed a 55-47 win. It was the final game for four seniors Alivia Koenig, Averey Rumer, Katie Prater and Ashley Eachus.
Bluffton led 10-9 after the first quarter however Arlington owned the middle two stanzas to take control of the game. The Red Devils never employed their full court trapping press but instead focused on taking away open three pointers on the outside and relying on their superior height in the interior. The result was Bluffton only scoring 12 points in the second and third periods combined while shooting 3/22 inside the arc and 2/6 outside. Arlington out scored Bluffton 32-12 in the middle two quarters and owned a 41-22 lead heading into the fourth quarter.
Things finally opened up for the Pirates over the final eight minutes. BHS connected on five three pointers in the fourth quarter including three from Rumer. Koenig and Kayla White each added another shot from distance. Koenig was fouled on her make with 3:19 to go. The free throw was missed but Bluffton had the lead down to 47-38. Rumer sank two free throws and then nailed a ‘3’ with 1:45 to go to bring Bluffton within four points. Following an Arlington turnover, one of five in the fourth quarter, Koenig scored in the lane to bring the Pirates to within two. AHS scored in transition followed by two more Koenig free throws at the 1:08 mark to set the score at 49-47.
The Pirates continued to foul and Arlington made all six free throw attempts over the final minute. The Pirates misfired on three shots over the final minute and had a turnover as well. Rumer scored 11 fourth quarter points and Koenig 7 as the Pirates furious rally fell just short.
Bluffton ends the year at 19-6 and advanced to the District level of the OHSAA tournament for the first time since 2005.
Team Statistics (unofficial)
Bluffton
2FG 9/32 (28%)
3FG (53%)
FT (41%)
REB 22
Turnovers 11
Arlington
2FG 20/42 (48%)
3FG 1/10 (10%)
FT 12/18 (67%)
REB 31 (14 offensive)
Turnovers 14
Individual Pirate Scoring
Averey Rumer - 17 points, 3/4 on 3s, 5 rebounds
Alivia Koenig - 12 points, two 3s, 4 rebounds
Kayla White - 6 points, 2/2 on 3s, 1 rebound
Katie Prater - 6 points, 2 rebounds
Brinkley Garmatter - 3 points, one 3
Ashley Eachus - 2 points, 3 rebounds
Libby Schaadt - 1 point, 8 rebounds
Stories Posted This Week
Tuesday, November 10, 2026
- Letter: Thank you, Coach Richards
- Big Brothers Big Sisters launches 2026 year-end giving campaign
- Socktober drive collected 659 pairs for local distribution
- Jeanne Previte, 80, owned and operated Jeanne's Kitchen
- Bluffton Elementary Honor Roll for 1st Quarter 2026-2027
- Lego scarecrow earns GROB top honors from voters
- Former Blufftonite is lieutenant governor-elect of South Carolina
- University to stage costume drama that mixes emotion, humor and contemporary references
- Bluffton High School Honor Roll for 1st quarter of 2026-2027
- Nov. 13 chamber program on Opportunities for Ohioans with Disabilities
Monday, November 9, 2026
- Healing and life beyond incarceration explored at Forum
- Nov. 12 opportunity to learn Mahjong
- Door hanger craft class at Pandora library, November 17
- BPL after school movie, November 16
- Hailey's Wellness and Massage provide chair massages at Senior Center
- Bluffton area Women in Business Meeting November 19
Sunday, November 8, 2026
Saturday, November 7, 2026
- Pirates Essinger and Gatchel finish cross country season at OHSAA Championships
- Nov. 7 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup, streaming
- Pirate football hits Archbold roadblock in playoff loss
- Forum: Vaughn explores biblical and multicultural accounts of spirits and exorcism
- Bluffton University relaunches Leadership Development Program with NetVUE grant support
- Weekend Doctor: When distraction becomes the default