Baylor Garmatter and Libby Schaadt were named the 2020 Jim “Cappy” Clark winners, recognizing them as the most outstanding athletes in this year’s senior class at Bluffton High School.

Libby Schaadt
Libby Schaadt plans to attend Tiffin University and major in management. Here are some of her high school athletic achievements:

Softball: Three year player; team MVP as a freshman. As a junior, NWC player of the year; first team district; broke her own school strikeout record; set school home run record; second team all-state.

Volleyball: Four year player; honorable mention NWC.

Basketball: Four year player; honorable mention NWC; second team NWC, set school single-game rebound record, team MVP.

Baylor Garmatter
Baylor Garmatter plans to attend Purdue and major in engineering. Here are some of his high school athletic achievements:

Football: four-year starter, three-time honorable mention NWC.

Basketball: two-year starter, best game vs. eventual state champ Crestview (BHS won).

Track: Regional 400 champ; advanced to state meet three years; as a freshman and sophomore in the 4 by 800 relay; as a junior in the 4 by 400 relay and as an individual in the 400.

About the Jim “Cappy” Clark Award
Although not at first, today the award is called the Jim “Cappy” Clark Award. 

Clark attended Bluffton High School in the 1940s. During his lifetime, his interest in youth sports was immense. In the 1950s he founded the midget football program in Bluffton. At one time he coached three midget teams: the Pirates, Beavers and Buccaneers.

He retired from coaching the midget Pirates in 1980, after a 25-year career. During that period at least nine of his teams were league champs or playoff contenders.

A student’s selection as a Cappy Clark winner is based upon that student lettering in two or more sports, an accumulative grade point average of 2.5 or higher and consideration such as sportsmanship, athletic leadership, school leadership and citizenship. Each year’s winners are chosen by the athletic department and coaching staff.

Cappy Clark Award Winners

BOYS
1966 – Bill Swank
1967 – David Burkholder
1968 – Steve Stratton
1969 – Melvin Benroth

1970 – Mike Osborne
1971 – Dean King
1972 – Jim King
1973 – Steve Shaw
1974 – Mark Phillips
1975 – Dave Stratton
1976 – Jeff Shaw
1977 – Jeff Pogue
1978 – Bruce Matter
1979 – Tim Closson/Jeff Alt

1980 – Mardy Herr
1981 – Don Mathewson
1982 – Jeff Swank
1983 – John Tabler
1984 – Mike Yoder
1985 – Paul Shelly
1986 – Bruce Yant
1987 – Jim Armstrong
1988 – Doug Schweingruber
1989 – Curt Garmatter

1990 – Dan Althaus
1991 – Jeff Martz
1992 – Jeremy Herr
1993 – Matthew Derstine
1994 – Matthew Schweingruber
1995 – Jon Osborne
1996 – Eric Smith
1997 – Cam Warner
1998 – Rick Orr
1999 – Lucas Cherry

2000 – Kurt McKibben
2001 – Jon Wietholter
2002 – Ben Wenger
2003 – Ben McCullough
2004 – Jeff Richards
2005 – Justin Shannon
2006 – Kurt Groman
2007 – Andrew Hieronimus
2008 – Jesse Herr
2009 – Tyler Neal

2010 – Matt Suderman
2011 – Drew Luginbuhl
2012 – Jeremy Basinger
2013 – Zach Wilson
2014 – Noah Stratton
2015 – Robbie Stratton
2016 – Joel Siefker
2017 – Trevor Bassitt
2018 – Kaleb Jefferson
2019 – DeAndre Nassar
2020 – Baylor Garmatter

GIRLS
1979- Venessa Beach
1980 – Julee Matter
1981 – AAmy Bixel
1982 – Tammy Plaugher
1983 – Amy Osborne
1984 – Mary Steiner
1985 – Julie Shelly
1986 – Wendy Smith
1987 – Cindy Badertscher
1988 – Kris Snyder
1989 – Julie Friesen

1990 – Rachel Hefner
1991 – Angie Butler
1992 – Eliza Jacoby
1993 – Elizabeth Edwards
1994 – Rebecca Reineke
1995 – Crystal Bennett
1996 – Janni Sprunger
1997 -  Ann Stechschulte
1998 – Katie Kantner
1999 – Anna Steiner

2000 – Caity Matter
2001 – Jennifer Romey
2002 – Mollie McCullough
2003 – Carrie Fett
2004 – Kelly Metzger
2005 – Emily Goldsberry
2006 – Ginny Buckingham
2007 – Brittany Buroker
2008 – Amanda Stratton
2009 – Jonica Schmutz
2010 – Sarah Stratton

2011 – Shannon McKamey
2012 – Lydia Guagenti
2013 – Julie  Althaus
2014 – Jill Steinmetz
2015 – Erica Sheehan
2016 – Samantha Fruchey
2017 – Abbie Parkins
2018 – Abbey Gambrell
2019 – Kaitlyn Prater
2020 – Libby Schaadt