Lewis Carroll and Robert Frost were no-shows for Thanksgiving dinner; even so, the oyster stew was perfect
Our Thanksgiving dinner invitation list included favorite poets Lewis Carroll and Robert Frost. Neither accepted, but places were set.
Set, just in case of late arrivals.
Hoping for Mister Carroll’s presence, for days prior to Thanksgiving lines from “Oh, oysters come and walk with us… along the briny beach”… chanted frequently around our cheery home.
It didn’t work.
It didn’t work, even though we ordered a fresh pint of the delicacy from The Dough Hook and informed our poet friend of the menu: Oyster Stew.
The only sign of Mister Frost on Thanksgiving morn was a dusty residue of white stuff on the lawn.
And, his no-show changed our recipe plans for the stew.
We diverged down the road taken instead of the one that made all the difference, opting for a quicker recipe from “Better Homes and Garden New Cookbook – Limited Edition.” We found eariler that “The Joy of Cooking” recipe took longer and required a double boiler.
That said, here’s how we – or should I say, I – prepared fresh oyster stew for Thanksgiving. Neither Wanda Suter Pannabecker nor her lovely daughter, Mary Beth, accepted a serving.
Both, apologized - as the soup ladle passed their plates – mumbling something about allergies to shellfish.
I know better. It was the half-and-half.
None-the-less, here’s the oyster stew recipe chosen and consumed:
Icon Poet Oyster Stew
¼ cup chopped green onion
1 tablespoon butter
1 pint fresh, undrained oysters (shucked)
½ teaspoon salt
2 cups half-and-half
1 cup fat free milk
Handful of fresh cut parsley
¼ teaspoon pepper
Place onions and butter in a large skillet. Heat until butter melts. Next, drop in the salt and oysters – including the liquid. Stir.
Let it boil and then turn to simmer. Let it cook for 5 minutes and don’t forget to stir from time to time.
Pour in the half-and-half, the milk, parsley and pepper. Allow it to heat up again. Then serve with some oyster crackers.
Optional: Recitation of “The Road Not Taken,” and “The Sun Was Shining On The Sea.”
Stories Posted This Week
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Monday, November 16, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, November 9-15
- Home Energy Assistance Program (HEAP) reminder
- Training opportunities expand for Putnam County students
- Cory-Rawson High School Honor Roll for first nine weeks of 2026-2027
- Teens invited to give macrame a try, Nov. 30
- Swiss Heritage Center ribbon cutting and Christmas Open House celebrations
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Saturday, November 14, 2026
- Pirate bowling opens season vs. Kenton at Southgate Lanes
- Weekend Doctor: Preventing overuse injuries in young athletes
- Northwest Ohio Orthopedics and Sports Medicine to join Blanchard Valley Health System in 2027
- Fett, Warwick and Hudson win BACC photo competition
- Icon sponsors shine a spotlight on Ada and Bluffton
Friday, November 13, 2026
- 55th annual Carol Sing at Riley Creek UMC, Dec. 6
- Next Generation 911 announced by Hancock County
- Christine Denecker appointed to Ohio Humanities Council
- Community Electric Aggregation notices are in the mail to Bluffton customers
- Nov. 13 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup
- Letter: What a fall for our Bluffton Pirates