How about a hickory nut and black walnut pie for Christmas dinner?
Someone once said that there is nothing better in life than taking a pie out of the oven.
Some pie lovers might say that there’s nothing better in life than ordering a custom-baked Dr. Oliver Lugibihl hickory nut and black walnut pie.
And, this month you can have your Lugibihl pie and eat it too, pre-ordered from the Service Group of Mennonite Home Communities of Ohio.
The service group is accepting pie orders available for Christmas now through Friday, Dec. 19.
Pies are available at $25 each with all proceeds supporting the projects of the service group. To place an order call MHCO at 419-358-1015, extension 211, Mondays through Fridays from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Background on the Oliver Lugibihl pie
A couple years ago the Icon watched Dr. Lugibihl during one of his pie-baking sessions. Here’s part of that interview:
To the question, “Why did you start baking hickory nut pies?” pie-baker Lugibihl replied, “I probably didn’t have any pecans.”
Then came a grin.
The grin occurred between his breaking a jumbo Moser egg and measuring out some Watkins vanilla, which he insists he likes better than other vanilla, “because of its stronger flavor.”
Known as the hickory nut pie man, Icon viewers have a rare, seasonal opportunity to purchase one his masterpiece pies this month.
“When I retired I wanted to do some of the things I remembered as a kid,” said Lugibihl, who served the Bluffton-Pandora communities in medical practice as a general practitioner.
About five years ago he started to do one of those “things.”
He started baking hickory nut pies. He made 38 in his first year for the Bluffton Fall Festival. Since then he’s baked dozens of the pies as fundraisers for the Service Group of the Mennonite Home Communities of Ohio and also Grace Mennonite Church, Pandora.
Pies are baked two at a time, “because they don’t bake quite right if you put more than two in the oven at the same time,” he said. And, concerning the two in the oven, bake them for 50 minutes at 325 degrees.
“If the pie jiggles after 50 minutes, leave it in a little longer,” he said. Each pie, in a 10-inch crust, contains one and one-half cups of nuts.
The hickory nut harvest occurs at the end of August and goes into September and October.
The nuts used in this year’s pies are from the previous fall.
Back to the pies, in Lugibihl’s garage hang bags of hickory nuts and more nuts, from last year, fill his freezer.
He jokingly said, the nuts here are from “cradle to grave.” Adding, “If you know hickory nuts, you know these pies are worth it.”
Stories Posted This Week
Monday, November 16, 2026
- Beavers sports roundup, November 9-15
- Home Energy Assistance Program (HEAP) reminder
- Training opportunities expand for Putnam County students
- Cory-Rawson High School Honor Roll for first nine weeks of 2026-2027
- Teens invited to give macrame a try, Nov. 30
- Swiss Heritage Center ribbon cutting and Christmas Open House celebrations
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Saturday, November 14, 2026
- Pirate bowling opens season vs. Kenton at Southgate Lanes
- Weekend Doctor: Preventing overuse injuries in young athletes
- Northwest Ohio Orthopedics and Sports Medicine to join Blanchard Valley Health System in 2027
- Fett, Warwick and Hudson win BACC photo competition
- Icon sponsors shine a spotlight on Ada and Bluffton
Friday, November 13, 2026
- 55th annual Carol Sing at Riley Creek UMC, Dec. 6
- Next Generation 911 announced by Hancock County
- Christine Denecker appointed to Ohio Humanities Council
- Community Electric Aggregation notices are in the mail to Bluffton customers
- Nov. 13 Bluffton Schools athletics lineup
- Letter: What a fall for our Bluffton Pirates
Thursday, November 12, 2026
- Bluffton Middle School Honor Roll for 1st Quarter, 2026-2027
- Bluffton alumni to discuss lives and vocations in ministry
- Letter: Honoring 20 years of land preservation in West Central Ohio
- Prairie restoration research program on Nov. 20
- Bluffton Lions to hear presentation on humanitarian and disaster relief
- Separate the wheat from the chaff: Multi-ingredient botanicals for cholesterol